20180821-广发证券_香港_-Emerging_Market_Currency_Crisis__Who_s_Next__12页_847kb

Emerging Market Currency Crisis Summary

Core Content

This document analyzes the current risk of currency crises in emerging markets, highlighting the impact of the strengthening US dollar and the deterioration of key economic indicators. It suggests that while some countries like Argentina, Turkey, and Brazil have already experienced significant currency depreciation, others including Egypt, South Africa, Iran, Colombia, and Nigeria may face similar challenges if the dollar continues to rise. The report also provides a framework for identifying currency risks using seven key indicators and compares the current situation with the 1997 Asian financial crisis.

Main Points

• US Dollar Strength: The dollar index has risen over 7% since mid-April 2018, driven by the Fed's rate hikes and reduced quantitative easing.
• Currency Depreciation in Emerging Markets: Argentina, Turkey, and Brazil have seen sharp depreciation, with Turkey's lira falling over 25% against the dollar in one week.
• Factors Driving Currency Crises:
  • Rising US Treasury yields attracting capital inflows into the US.
  • Weak real exchange rates, low foreign exchange reserves, high inflation, and large current account deficits.
  • Excessive credit growth and fiscal deficits.
• Key Indicators for Currency Crisis Prediction:
  • Real exchange rate
  • Foreign exchange reserves
  • GDP growth
  • Current account
  • Credit growth
  • Inflation
  • Fiscal surplus
• Current Market Conditions:
  • Emerging markets are in a better position than in 1997, with improved foreign exchange reserves, credit growth, and inflation conditions.
  • A large-scale crisis is unlikely unless key indicators deteriorate rapidly.

Key Information

• Countries at Risk:
  • Most Likely: Egypt and South Africa due to poor performance in most of the seven indicators.
  • Likely: Iran, Colombia, and Nigeria, as they also show significant weaknesses in several indicators.
• Capital Controls: The openness of a country's capital account is a critical factor in its vulnerability to currency crises. Open systems are more prone to depreciation, while Wall systems (like China and India) are more stable.
• Historical Comparison:
  • Compared to the 1997 crisis, emerging markets now have better fundamentals, especially in foreign exchange reserves and fiscal conditions.
  • However, the real exchange rate and GDP growth remain similar, indicating continued risks.
• Policy Response:
  • Central banks in affected countries have raised interest rates to stabilize their currencies.
  • Capital controls have been implemented in some cases, such as in Argentina and China, to prevent further depreciation.

Who's Next?

• Egypt: Five of its seven indicators are marked in red, indicating a high likelihood of a currency crisis.
• South Africa: Has low foreign exchange reserves and a large current account deficit, making it vulnerable.
• Iran: Shows a low GDP growth rate but high credit and inflation growth.
• Colombia and Nigeria: Also face significant risks, though not as high as Egypt and South Africa.

The Worst is Yet to Come

• Current Conditions: Emerging markets are not in as bad a position as during the 1997 crisis, with higher foreign exchange reserves and better credit and inflation management.
• Risk Outlook: While a large-scale crisis is unlikely, localized or regional crises could still occur, especially in countries with weak fundamentals and poor capital controls.
• Dollar Index Projection: The dollar index is expected to continue rising, potentially reaching close to 100, which could increase pressure on emerging market currencies.

Conclusion

The strengthening of the US dollar and the deterioration of several key economic indicators pose a risk to emerging markets. However, the current state of these economies is more resilient than in the past, reducing the likelihood of a full-scale crisis. The most vulnerable countries are Egypt and South Africa, followed by Iran, Colombia, and Nigeria. Capital controls and monetary policy adjustments are crucial in mitigating these risks.