20160603-法国巴黎银行-How_much_longer_to_the_debt_cliff__11页_368kb_368kb

Summary of China's Debt Situation

Core Content

China's debt situation has become a major concern for investors, particularly due to the increasing number of default cases and the overall high debt ratio. The report highlights the structure, growth, and challenges of China's debt, as well as the potential for a financial crisis and the government's capacity to manage it.

Main Points

• Aggregate Debt Level:
  The total debt of the real economy in China reached RMB166t by the end of 2015, equivalent to 245% of GDP. This includes household debt (40% of GDP), government debt (56% of GDP), and non-financial corporate debt (149% of GDP).

  • Household debt: RMB27t (up 433% since 2007)
  • Government debt: RMB38t (up 259% since 2007)
  • Corporate debt: RMB100.9t (up 337% since 2007)

• Debt Growth:
  Total debt increased by 328% from RMB39t in 2007 to RMB166t in 2015, with an annual growth rate of about 20%.

  • Debt to GDP ratio rose from 145% in 2007 to 245% in 2015, an increase of 100 percentage points.

• Debt Structure:
  China's debt structure is dominated by loans, with only 3.4% of total social financing coming from equity markets.

  • 69.2% of TSF is from formal bank loans
  • 8.1% from entrusted loans
  • 3.9% from trust loans
  • 3.7% from bankers' acceptance bills
  • 11.1% from corporate bonds

• Non-Performing Loans (NPL):

  • The estimated NPL ratio for on-balance sheet loans is 8.5%, significantly higher than the official 1.67%.
  • Total NPL could be as high as RMB14t, with bad loans potentially reaching RMB8.4t if 60% of NPL turns bad.
  • NPLs are concentrated in SOEs, real estate, and industry sectors.

• Debt Issues:
  The report identifies five key problems related to China's debt situation:

  1. Ambiguous debt statistics
  2. Rapid debt growth
  3. High corporate debt
  4. High debt servicing costs
  5. High NPL

• International Comparison:
  China's debt ratio is relatively high compared to other economies, especially in the corporate sector.

  • Corporate debt to GDP: 149% (China) vs. 86% (advanced economies) and 101% (emerging markets)
  • Government debt to GDP: 56% (China) vs. 106% (advanced economies) and 42% (emerging markets)

• Government Capacity:
  Despite the high debt levels, the Chinese government is considered capable of managing the situation and preventing a crisis similar to the Asian Financial Crisis or Global Financial Crisis.

  • The government holds RMB127t in net assets, which can be mobilized.
  • Commercial banks hold RMB2.3t in provisions, providing a buffer.

• Debt Default Concerns:
  The report notes that the government is unable to protect all borrowers, and the concept of "too big to fail" is no longer applicable.

  • SOEs, in particular, have been increasingly defaulting on interest and principal repayments.
  • The government may have to allow some defaults to occur, which could lead to write-offs and asset restructurings.

• Solutions and Outlook:
  The government is working on solutions, including:

  1. Controlling new debt growth and shifting to a more passive monetary policy
  2. Resolving zombie company debts through asset restructuring and write-offs
  3. Encouraging debt-equity swaps based on market forces
  4. Rolling over NPLs, with potential for losses to be shared among SOEs, lenders, and investors

Key Information

• The debt ratio in China is high due to a poorly developed equity market and reliance on debt financing.
• The government debt ratio is 56% of GDP in 2015, while local government debt is estimated at RMB17.4t.
• The report estimates that the actual debt level may be higher than the reported RMB166t due to unaccounted forms like private lending and shadow financing.
• The NPL ratio is estimated at 8.5%, with total NPL potentially reaching RMB14t.
• The Chinese government has the resources and capacity to prevent a systemic crisis, but the resolution process is complex and will require time.
• The debt problem is exacerbated by slowing growth, supply-side restructuring, and overcapacity in traditional industries.

Conclusion

While China's debt situation is concerning, the government is actively working on solutions to manage the risks and prevent a financial crisis. The report suggests that the debt cliff may not be immediate, but the challenges remain significant and require careful handling.