2023-12-21-国际清算银行-通货膨胀对家庭资产负债表的异质性影响_36页_1mb

Summary of BIS Working Paper No. 1152: The Heterogeneous Impact of Inflation on Households' Balance Sheets

Core Content

This BIS Working Paper analyzes how inflation affects wealth inequality across different households. It identifies and quantifies three key channels through which inflation impacts individuals' real wealth: the wealth (Fisher) channel, the income channel, and the relative consumption channel. The study uses detailed and high-frequency data from BBVA to examine the impact of the 2021 inflation surge in Spain, which was largely unexpected and perceived as temporary.

Main Channels of Inflation Impact

1. Wealth (Fisher) Channel

• Inflation redistributes wealth from creditors to debtors by altering the nominal value of assets and liabilities.
• This channel is captured through the net nominal position (NNP), which is the difference between nominal assets and liabilities.
• The impact of this channel is significant, as it reflects the real value changes in financial assets and debts.
• The paper builds on previous studies, such as those by Doepke and Schneider (2006), Meh et al. (2010), and others, which have explored similar mechanisms.

2. Income Channel

• Inflation reduces the real value of nominal income, including wages, unemployment benefits, and pensions.
• These income sources are often sticky, meaning they are updated infrequently (e.g., annually in Spain).
• The impact is proportional to the nominal income level, so higher-income households experience greater real wealth losses.
• This channel affects all households negatively, but the magnitude varies with income levels.

3. Relative Consumption Channel

• Inflation affects different goods and services at varying rates, leading to heterogeneous impacts on households depending on their consumption baskets.
• This channel is proportional to the individual's consumption expenditure and the ratio of individual inflation to aggregate inflation.
• Households that consume more of goods with higher price increases suffer greater wealth losses, while those with lower individual inflation rates benefit.
• This channel is connected to the literature on inflation inequality, which studies how different individuals experience inflation differently.

Key Findings

• The wealth and income channels are one order of magnitude larger than the relative consumption channel.
• Middle-aged individuals were largely unaffected by the 2021 inflation surge, while older individuals experienced the largest decline in real wealth.
• This is because middle-aged individuals have large negative NNP due to mortgages, while older individuals have large positive NNP.
• These results are confirmed using representative household surveys (EPF and EFF), which align with the findings from BBVA's client-level data.
• Individual inflation rates showed higher variability in 2022, suggesting that the relative consumption channel may have become more significant during that year.

Methodology and Data

• The study uses high-frequency client-level data from BBVA, which includes transactions, income, and balance sheet information for individuals.
• This data allows for weekly tracking of consumption and income, which is more detailed than the annual frequency of traditional surveys.
• The paper introduces a theoretical framework that decomposes the impact of inflation on wealth into the three identified channels, based on assumptions about nominal wage rigidities and temporary inflation shocks.

Limitations and Future Work

• The paper assumes that general equilibrium effects are not significant in the short run, and that taxation, public spending, and other macroeconomic factors do not directly influence the immediate impact of inflation.
• The analysis is based on the unexpected and temporary nature of the 2021 inflation surge, which aligns with the assumptions of the model.
• The paper acknowledges that longer-term effects and dynamic adjustments to inflation are beyond its scope, and would require more complex models that incorporate equilibrium price determination and policy instruments.

Conclusion

The paper contributes to the growing literature on inflation inequality by quantifying the relative importance of the three channels. It provides empirical evidence that the wealth and income channels dominate the impact of inflation on households, with relative consumption playing a smaller role. The findings are consistent across survey data and client-level data, reinforcing the robustness of the analysis.