EBA欧洲银行-060209E-money_8页_178kb

The E-Money Directive's Benefits & Areas for Improvement Summary

Core Content

The E-Money Directive, introduced in the EU, has played a significant role in shaping the regulatory landscape for electronic money (e-money). It was designed as a deregulatory tool to lower entry barriers for the e-money industry and promote competition beyond traditional banks. However, it has also faced challenges due to its ambiguous definitions and the evolving nature of the e-money business model.

Main Points

• Inspirational Context: The speech begins with a humorous and reflective tone, acknowledging the challenge of delivering an inspirational message on a complex regulatory topic.

• Historical Perspective on Money: The speaker contrasts ancient forms of money with modern e-money, highlighting the rapid evolution of financial instruments and the shift to digital payments.

• PayPal as a Case Study: PayPal is used as an example of an e-money institution that offers buyer protection, which is not typically associated with traditional banking. In Germany, this service is considered part of the guarantee business, which is regulated as banking, but under a UK licence, it operates outside of German banking regulations.

• Definition of E-Money: The core challenge lies in the definition of e-money and e-money institutions. The EU's definition excludes traditional deposit-taking from the definition of e-money institutions, thus reducing their regulatory burden.

• Regulatory Framework: The E-Money Directive was not just a regulatory response to an existing product but an attempt to create a new business model: a low-risk deposit-taker offering electronically accessible deposits that are as safe as real money.

• Risks and Regulation: Despite the goal of a lighter regime, the directive imposed strict rules on the backing of e-money with high-quality assets, aiming to mitigate risks such as market, credit, and concentration risks. This approach was necessary to distinguish e-money from traditional deposits.

• Regulatory Process as Innovation: The speaker emphasizes that regulation is not just about rules but is a dynamic process that drives innovation in financial markets. Effective regulation requires communication with both the industry and other regulators.

• Lessons from Basel II: The experience with Basel II highlights the importance of a collaborative regulatory environment that fosters collective learning and intelligence. The UK's implementation of the E-Money Directive is noted as a successful example of this approach.

• Final Warning: The speaker concludes with a cautionary note about the "elephants" in regulatory definitions, suggesting that the directive's success depends on its ability to adapt to the evolving business model of e-money institutions.

Key Information

• E-money Definition: The directive defines e-money as a monetary value denominated in an EU Member State's currency, stored on a data medium, and transferable by electronic means. This definition excludes traditional deposit-taking, thus avoiding the full regulatory burden of banking.

• Regulatory Impact: The directive allows e-money institutions to operate under a lighter regulatory regime compared to traditional banks, which is a key benefit. This has encouraged innovation and competition in the digital payments space.

• Challenges: The directive faces criticism for its unclear definitions, particularly around the concept of "guarantee business" in Germany, which may lead to regulatory confusion.

• Communication and Collaboration: The successful implementation of the directive in the UK was due to extensive dialogue between regulators and the e-money industry, which is seen as a model for future revisions.

• Future Direction: The speaker suggests that the revision of the directive should focus on understanding and adapting to the evolved business model of e-money institutions rather than merely applying existing regulatory frameworks.

Conclusion

The E-Money Directive has been instrumental in fostering a competitive and innovative e-money market in Europe. However, it requires careful review to ensure that its regulatory framework remains relevant and effective in the face of evolving technologies and business models. The directive is not just a regulatory tool but a framework that has helped shape the modern financial landscape.