BIS国际清算银行-The-economic-forces-driving-fintech-adoption-across-countries_16页_367kb

Summary of "The Economic Forces Driving Fintech Adoption Across Countries"

Core Content

This paper by Jon Frost explores the economic factors that influence the adoption of financial technology (fintech) across different countries. It highlights the uneven global spread of fintech, focusing on the forces that drive its growth in some regions and not in others.

Main Points

1. Fintech Adoption is Uneven

• Fintech adoption varies significantly across countries.
• It is not uniformly correlated with economic development or political boundaries.
• Certain cities, such as Hangzhou, Seattle, and Tel Aviv, have become fintech hubs, while traditional financial centers like Tokyo and Milan show lower fintech activity.

2. Key Drivers of Fintech Adoption

a. Unmet Demand for Financial Services

• In developing and emerging market economies (EMDEs), fintech adoption is often driven by unmet demand for financial services.
• Fintech helps to increase financial inclusion, especially in areas where traditional banking is limited or inaccessible.
• Example: M-Pesa in Kenya has expanded to multiple countries, providing basic banking and payment services to millions.

b. High Cost of Traditional Finance

• In countries where financial services are expensive, fintech adoption is more pronounced.
• The high cost of finance is often linked to limited competition and high banking sector mark-ups.
• Fintech can reduce transaction costs and improve efficiency, making it more attractive in such markets.

c. Supportive Regulatory Environment

• A regulatory environment that is permissive to new entrants can foster fintech growth.
• Regulatory factors, such as ease of entry and quality of regulation, are associated with higher fintech credit volumes.
• However, regulatory arbitrage is not a primary driver of fintech adoption at the aggregate level.

d. Changing Demographics and Trust

• Younger generations (e.g., millennials) are more likely to trust and adopt fintech services.
• Trust in technology firms is a key enabler of fintech adoption, particularly in countries with younger populations.
• Conversely, older populations may still rely on cash, and trust in fintech may decline due to data breaches and scandals ("techlash").

3. Fintech's Role in Financial Inclusion and Efficiency

• Fintech can enhance financial inclusion by providing access to credit, insurance, and wealth management services to underserved populations.
• It can also improve the efficiency of financial systems, especially in EMDEs where traditional banking is limited.
• The paper notes that fintech is particularly impactful in retail financial services, such as mobile payments and peer-to-peer (P2P) lending.

4. Fintech in Different Financial Sectors

• Payments: Mobile payments are growing rapidly in EMDEs, especially where mobile phone penetration is high.
• Credit: Fintech credit is becoming economically significant in some markets, such as the US, UK, and China, but remains limited in others like Continental Europe and Latin America.
• Insurance and Asset Management: Fintech is also making inroads into insurance and wealth management through "insurtech" and "robo-advisors".
• Wholesale Markets: Fintech penetration is still low in wholesale financial markets, such as trade finance, syndicated lending, and derivatives trading, despite the potential of distributed ledger technology (DLT).

5. Implications for Economic Growth and Risk

a. Positive Impacts

• Fintech can support economic growth by expanding access to financial services and improving efficiency.
• It can enhance cross-border financial integration and diversify financial risk across economies.

b. Potential Risks

• Fintech activities are still subject to traditional market failures, such as information asymmetry, adverse selection, and liquidity mismatches.
• Large fintech or big tech firms may become systemically important, leading to moral hazard and excessive risk-taking.
• Interconnectedness in fintech systems can transmit market shocks across institutions and markets.

Key Findings

• Fintech adoption is more prevalent in markets with unmet demand for financial services, high costs of traditional finance, and supportive regulatory environments.
• Younger demographics and trust in technology are important enablers of fintech growth.
• While fintech can enhance financial inclusion and economic efficiency, it also carries risks that require careful regulation and supervision.
• Regulatory arbitrage is not the main driver of fintech adoption at the aggregate level, though it may play a role in specific activities.
• Fintech's impact is still limited in terms of scale, accounting for only about 0.14% of global financial system assets in 2017.

Conclusion

Fintech adoption is driven by a mix of demand-side and supply-side factors. In EMDEs, unmet demand for financial services is a major driver, while in advanced economies, the high cost of traditional finance and supportive regulations also play a role. Although fintech can support economic growth and financial inclusion, it remains subject to traditional financial risks and requires appropriate public policy responses to ensure stability and sustainability.