2010年-世界发展银行全球_Public_Procurement_of_Energy_Efficiency_Services___Getting_Started_36页_2mb
报告摘要
Summary of "Public Procurement of Energy Efficiency Services"
Core Content
The document "Public Procurement of Energy Efficiency Services: Lessons from International Experience" discusses the potential of energy efficiency (EE) in the public sector as a critical tool for sustainable energy development. It highlights the growing global energy demand and the need for innovative solutions to meet this demand in an environmentally and economically viable manner. Public procurement is identified as a significant opportunity to drive EE improvements, particularly in government-owned facilities, which represent a large portion of a country’s GDP.
Main Points
- Global Energy Demand: The world's energy needs are expected to grow rapidly, with the largest increase in developing countries. This will require over $25 trillion in energy infrastructure investment by 2030.
- Benefits of Energy Efficiency: EE measures offer multiple benefits, including improved energy security, reduced environmental impact, cost savings, and enhanced competitiveness. They are often viewed as "no regrets" policies due to their high financial returns.
- Public Sector Potential: The public sector holds significant potential for EE improvements, especially given the scale of its operations and the opportunity to bundle projects for cost-effective implementation.
- Energy Savings Performance Contracts (ESPCs): ESPCs are a promising model for public sector EE projects. They allow energy service providers (ESPs) to finance and implement EE upgrades, with payments coming from the energy cost savings. This reduces the financial burden on public agencies and encourages participation in EE programs.
- Challenges in Public Procurement: Public agencies face several challenges in implementing EE projects, including rigid procurement practices, limited budgets, lack of technical expertise, and split-incentive issues between budgeting and operational agencies.
Key Information
Benefits of Energy Efficiency in the Public Sector
- Economic: Reduces public energy expenses, creating fiscal space for other investments.
- Environmental: Lowers greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and supports climate change mitigation.
- Social: Enhances reliability of energy systems and supports local employment through retrofitting and upgrading projects.
ESPCs: A New Way to Procure EE Services
- Model Overview: ESPCs involve ESPs providing a range of services (including financing) to public agencies, with payments based on energy savings.
- Advantages:
- Off-budget financing.
- Lower transaction costs due to project bundling.
- Leverage of commercial ESP expertise.
- Ability to pay for projects from energy savings.
- Disadvantages:
- Complex procurement and budgeting procedures.
- Risks associated with project design and performance guarantees.
- Potential for monopolistic behavior in certain models.
Emerging Models for ESPC Procurement
| No. | Model | Description | Cases |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Indefinite Contracting | Umbrella agency procures ESPs and allows direct contracts with selected ESPs. | US (FEMP), Hungary (MOE) |
| 2. | Public ESP | Publicly owned ESP, no competitive procurement. | Ukraine (Rivne City) |
| 2a. | Super ESP | Public ESP subcontracts with smaller ESPs. | US (NYPA), Belgium (Fedesco), India (EESL) |
| 2b. | Utility ESP | Public entity contracts directly with utility for EE services. | US (UESC), Croatia (HEP ESCO), Uruguay (USCO UTE) |
| 2c. | Utility Demand-Side Management ESP | ESP uses funds from a DSM surcharge. | Brazil |
| 2d. | Internal ESP (PICO) | Unit within public agency acts as ESP. | Germany (Stuttgart) |
| 3. | Energy Supply Contracting (Chauffage) | Contract for specific energy services (e.g., lighting, heating). | France, Germany, Austria |
| 4. | Procurement Agent | Quasi-public entity or NGO helps develop RFPs and contracts. | Germany, US (NYSERDA), Czech Republic (SEVEN) |
| 5. | Project Bundling | Umbrella agency bids for a group of buildings. | Austria, Germany, South Africa (Johannesburg), India (CPWD, TNUDF), US (California) |
| 6. | Nodal Agencies | Dedicated agencies facilitate procurement and financing. | US (USDOE), South Korea (KEMCO), India (BEE), Japan (ECCJ) |
| 7. | Ad Hoc | No explicit program, but no policy to prevent ESPCs. | Brazil, South Africa, China, Mexico, Egypt, Poland |
Barriers to Implementing ESPCs
- Lack of Awareness and Information: Governments and agencies may not be aware of EE products, their benefits, or the potential for savings.
- Technical Capacity Constraints: Limited expertise in energy audits, project design, and implementation.
- Incentive and Budget Issues: Lack of incentives for implementing EE and limited discretionary budgets.
- Procurement and Financing Rules: Rigid procurement procedures and limited flexibility in financing.
- Transaction Costs: High costs for small-scale projects and limited economies of scale.
- Split-Incentive Problem: Budgeting agencies may not be responsible for energy cost savings, leading to misalignment of incentives.
Recommendations for ESPC Procurement
| Main Steps | Recommendations |
|---|---|
| Budgeting | Start with more autonomous entities, gain support from parent agencies, and develop financing programs after initial projects. |
| Energy Audit | Define project scope with necessary technical information, and avoid overly prescriptive requirements. |
| Bidding Documents | Define projects carefully, consider broader parameters, and avoid premature standardization. |
| Evaluation Process | Use a two-stage evaluation process, prioritizing technical and financial indicators. |
| Financing | Use credit guarantees in high-risk markets, and develop dedicated EE funds in immature markets. |
| Contracting | Designate institutions to support ESPC projects, develop standardized contracts, and include M&V (measurement and verification) plans. |
Conclusion
The document emphasizes that while the public sector presents a significant opportunity for EE improvements, the implementation of ESPCs requires overcoming a range of barriers. It outlines various models and strategies for successful procurement and financing of EE services, providing both general and country-specific insights. The key takeaway is that a flexible, well-designed approach to public procurement of EE services can lead to substantial energy savings, cost reductions, and environmental benefits, supporting both sustainable development and economic growth.
试读结束,高清完整版pdf/doc/ppt,请点下载