EBA欧洲银行-Com_AnnexesI_VII15062007_000_111页_959kb

CEBS Technical Advice Summary: Commodities Business Regulation in the United States and EU Markets

Core Content

This document provides an analysis of the prudential risks associated with commodities business under Article 48 of Directive 2006/49/EC, with a specific focus on the regulatory framework in the United States and the characteristics of various commodities markets in the EU.

U.S. Commodities Regulation

Scope of Regulation

• Commodities and derivatives business in the U.S. is primarily regulated under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), which governs the futures and options industries.
• The CEA requires commodity futures and options to be traded on organized exchanges.
• The CEA does not explicitly define commodities, but in practice, a futures contract is a legally binding agreement to buy or sell a specific quantity of a commodity at a set price on a designated exchange.
• Spot or cash transactions and forward contracts are not covered by the CEA, though forward contracts may be subject to other regulations.

Regulatory Framework

• The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) administers the CEA.
• The CEA was revised in 2000 by the Commodity Futures Modernization Act (CFMA) to promote innovation and reduce systemic risk by introducing a tiered regulatory approach.

Market Participants and Trading Facilities

• Eligible Contract Participants (ECPs): Sophisticated traders such as financial institutions, insurance companies, and government entities.
• Eligible Commercial Entities (ECEs): A subset of ECPs that have the ability to make or take delivery of the underlying commodity.
• Other traders: Includes retail customers and smaller businesses.
• Trading facilities are divided into three tiers:
  • Designated Contract Markets (DCMs): Subject to the most comprehensive regulation, including registration and authorization.
  • Derivatives Transaction Execution Facilities (DTEFs): Require CFTC registration but have more limited oversight.
  • Exempt Markets: Subject to minimal CFTC oversight, including Exempt Commercial Markets (ECMs) and Exempt Boards of Trade (EBOTs).

Regulated Activities

• Futures Commission Merchants (FCMs): Brokers who handle customer funds must register with the CFTC and maintain adjusted net capital.
  • Minimum capital: $250,000 or 8% of risk margin requirement for customer positions, and 4% for own account positions.
  • NFA is the only registered futures association, so the de facto minimum capital is $500,000 for FCMs.
• Introducing Brokers (IBs): Must also register and maintain adjusted net capital.
  • Minimum capital: $30,000 or $45,000 if under NFA.
• Commodity Trading Advisors (CTAs) and Commodity Pool Operators (CPOs): Must register and meet disclosure and reporting requirements.
  • CTAs may be subject to enhanced supervisory requirements if their associated persons (APs) have worked at disciplined firms.
• Floor Brokers (FBs) and Floor Traders (FTs): Must register and are subject to self-regulatory oversight by DCMs or DTEFs.

Group Capital Requirements

• Intermediaries in a group are supervised consolidated if the parent company is a national bank (OCC) or a bank holding company (Federal Reserve Board).
• No minimum group capital requirements apply in these cases.
• For investment bank holding companies, a consolidated approach is allowed if the parent company files a notice with the SEC and meets certain conditions.

EU Commodities Markets Overview

Power Market

• Unique Characteristics:
  • Electricity cannot be stored, leading to high volatility and systemic risk.
  • OTC nature of the market increases exposure to CCR (Central Counterparty Risk).
  • Regional markets with limited cross-border physical trading due to grid constraints.
  • Most transactions are OTC, with forward and futures being the primary instruments.
  • Retail consumers are affected by price fluctuations due to the decline in long-term contracts.

Oil Market

• Market Overview:
  • Oil is refined into various products, and the supply chain involves multiple steps.
  • Prices are influenced by political and physical factors.
  • The oil derivative market is sufficiently liquid for risk assessment based on mark-to-market prices.
• Turnover: UK oil market turnover cleared through a clearinghouse is approximately $5,000 billion per year.

Gas Market

• Market Overview:
  • Annual EU gas consumption is 500 Bcm or 4,800 TWh.
  • Gas is used for electricity generation, heating, domestic fuel, and industrial production.
  • Indigenous production accounts for 43% of consumption, with the rest coming from Russia, Algeria, and Norway.
  • LNG is a growing component of the market, making gas a globally traded commodity.
• Market Turnover:
  • European gas markets have a turnover of 10,000 TWh or €400 billion.
  • Most trading is OTC, with London and the Netherlands (TTF) being the most liquid.

Coal Market

• Market Overview:
  • Approximately two-thirds of coal is used for power generation.
  • Coal is also used for heating and steel production.
  • The quality of coal affects its uses and is linked to freight and energy markets.
• Trading:
  • Financial products are OTC swaps on price indices or exchange contracts (e.g., NYMEX, EEX).
  • Physical trading is dominant, with a physical trade volume of over 700 million tonnes in 2005.

Metals and Precious Metals Market

• Market Overview:
  • The UK has a metals exchange, the London Metal Exchange (LME), which is a global center for base metals.
  • LME contracts are priced for physical delivery, but most are unwound before settlement.
  • Warrants are used for delivery, and can be obtained through deposit, borrowing, or warrants from earlier maturities.
• Market Turnover:
  • The LME has an annual turnover of over $4,500 billion, fully cleared.
  • The LME offers futures contracts up to 63 months for copper and aluminium.

Freight Market

• Market Overview:
  • Focuses on ocean-going vessel freight, excluding other types like road or inland freight.
  • Market is divided into dry and wet markets, based on cargo type.
  • FFAs (Forward Freight Agreements) are key instruments, introduced in 1991 in London.
  • IMAREX in Norway is the only regulated exchange for freight derivatives, with NOS as the clearing house.
  • LCH.Clearnet started clearing dry freight in 2005 and wet freight in 2006.
• Main Participants:
  • Dry Market: Institutions, commodity firms, ship operators, and hedge funds.
  • Wet Market: Institutions, oil traders, and ship-owners.
  • Hamburg brokers control 75% of the container freight market.

Key Risks and Considerations

• Systemic Risk: High in OTC markets due to limited CCR protection and market concentration.
• Market Volatility: Influenced by supply and demand imbalances, geopolitical events, and energy interdependencies.
• Regulatory Complexity: The U.S. regime is more complex due to the tiered approach, while EU markets are less regulated for certain commodities.
• Intermediary Oversight: DCMs and DTEFs are self-regulatory bodies, with the CFTC overseeing them through core principles.