卡内基国际和平基金会-Media-Call-Iran–Saudi-Arabia-Tensions_13页_202kb

Saudi-Iran Rivalry Analysis Summary

Core Content

The discussion revolves around the evolving dynamics between Saudi Arabia and Iran, focusing on the recent deterioration in their relations, the underlying causes, and the implications for U.S. foreign policy and regional stability.

Main Points

1. Nature of the Saudi-Iran Rivalry

• Strategic Competitors, Not Inherent Rivals: The rivalry is primarily geopolitical, not purely sectarian or ethnic.
• Historical Context: The two countries have had periods of cooperation and a "cold modus vivendi," even during periods of tension.
• Sectarian Influence: The Shia-Sunni divide has been exacerbated by regional instability, but it is not the main driver of the rivalry.

2. Domestic Politics in Saudi Arabia

• King Salman's Approach: The new king is leaning more towards conservative clerics and the Sunni establishment.
• Shia Situation: The Shia community, particularly in the Eastern Province, has seen increased repression, which has led to heightened tensions and potential for more unrest.
• Mohammed bin Salman's Role: As Crown Prince, he is using the Yemen conflict to bolster his domestic political standing, though the operation has not gone as planned.

3. Domestic Politics in Iran

• Rouhani's Pragmatic Agenda: President Rouhani seeks to open Iran to foreign investment and improve its international image.
• Elections and Candidates: The Guardian Council is likely to block many moderate candidates from running in upcoming parliamentary and Assembly of Experts elections.
• Saudi Investment in Iran: Despite the recent tensions, there has been significant Saudi private investment in Iran over the past decade, which contradicts the narrative of complete hostility.

4. U.S. Policy and Regional Implications

• Obama's Focus: The U.S. under Obama is prioritizing the Iran nuclear deal and is seeking to de-escalate tensions with Iran.
• Balancing Act: The U.S. is trying to maintain a balanced relationship with both Saudi Arabia and Iran, rather than taking sides.
• Defense Aid and Domestic Reform: There is speculation that the U.S. might reduce defense aid to Saudi Arabia to encourage domestic reform, but no concrete action is expected.

5. Regional Paranoia and Mutual Perceptions

• Saudi Obsession with Iran: Saudis view Iran as a major threat, especially in the context of regional conflicts and influence.
• Iranian Perspective: Iranians do not see Saudis as their primary threat, though they do have a sense of mutual chauvinism.
• Common Adversary: Both sides acknowledge ISIS as a common threat, but they attribute its rise to each other's policies, leading to a lack of cooperation.

Key Information

• The recent ransacking of the Saudi embassy in Tehran was likely a result of internal Iranian tensions, with the Revolutionary Guards and Basij militia involved.
• The U.S. is unlikely to reduce defense aid to Saudi Arabia immediately, due to domestic and economic considerations.
• The Saudi-Iran rivalry is expected to eventually reach an equilibrium, as seen in past periods of tension.
• The first 12–24 months of the Iran nuclear deal are critical, as internal Iranian groups may challenge its implementation.
• The Shia community in Saudi Arabia is becoming more radicalized due to repression and the threat from ISIS, which could lead to increased militancy.

Conclusion

The Saudi-Iran rivalry is a complex interplay of domestic politics, regional strategy, and international relations. While both countries are strategic competitors, they are not locked in an immutable conflict. The U.S. is seeking to manage this rivalry to protect the Iran nuclear deal and maintain stability in the region. The situation remains volatile, with potential for further escalation unless both sides can find a way to de-escalate tensions and work towards a more cooperative approach.