EBA欧洲银行-GL07_40页_495kb

Guidelines on the Recognition of External Credit Assessment Institutions (ECAIs) Summary

Core Content

These guidelines, issued by the Committee of European Banking Supervisors (CEBS), outline the process and criteria for recognizing External Credit Assessment Institutions (ECAIs) under the Capital Requirements Directive (CRD). The recognition of ECAIs is essential for credit institutions and investment firms to use external credit assessments in calculating risk weights under the Standardised Approach and the Securitisation Ratings Based Approaches.

Main Points

1. Purpose of ECAI Recognition

• ECAI recognition enables institutions to use external credit assessments for regulatory capital purposes.
• It does not constitute regulation or licensing of rating agencies in Europe.
• The recognition is solely for the purpose of determining risk weights in capital calculations.

2. Recognition Process

• Direct Recognition: Competent authorities assess the ECAI independently.
• Indirect Recognition: Competent authorities rely on recognition from another Member State, without conducting their own evaluation.
• CEBS promotes a common understanding to support consistent decision-making and reduce administrative burdens.

3. Joint Assessment Process

• When an ECAI applies for recognition in multiple Member States, competent authorities will collaborate in a joint assessment process.
• The goal is to achieve a shared view on the ECAI’s eligibility and mapping of credit assessments to the CRD's credit quality steps.
• A process facilitator is appointed to coordinate the joint assessment and produce a joint report.

4. Eligibility Criteria

• The CRD does not specify whether recognition should be at the group or subsidiary level.
• If an ECAI operates consistently across its group, it may apply at the group level.
• Subsidiaries using different methodologies must apply separately.
• 'Affiliates' or joint ventures are not included in group-level applications.

5. Common Basis Application Pack

• CEBS has developed a common basis application pack to ensure that all competent authorities request the same minimum information.
• The pack includes:
  • General information about the ECAI
  • Methodology used
  • Individual credit assessments
  • Mapping of credit assessments to credit quality steps
• Competent authorities may request additional information if needed for country-specific assessments.

6. Mapping Credit Assessments

• The mapping of ECAI assessments to the CRD's credit quality steps is based on qualitative and quantitative factors.
• The Basel Committee's guidance from the Basel II framework (Annex 2, June 2004) is recommended for mapping.
• Securitisation positions and Collective Investment Undertakings (CIUs) require special attention in the mapping process.

7. Transparency and Disclosure

• Competent authorities must disclose:
  • An explanation of their recognition process
  • A list of eligible ECAIs
• This information is part of the CEBS supervisory disclosure framework.
• The joint assessment report is shared with all competent authorities that received an application or intend to apply.

8. Collaboration and Coordination

• Competent authorities must be aware of each other’s involvement in the assessment of the same ECAI.
• CEBS encourages convergence in eligibility criteria and cooperation in the joint assessment process.
• The process facilitator ensures that:
  • Information is shared among participants
  • A clear timetable and workplan are established
  • Communication with ECAIs and institutions is coordinated

Key Information

• The recognition process is initiated by an application to the competent authority.
• Institutions may not apply on behalf of their subsidiaries for ECAI recognition.
• Indirect recognition is encouraged to improve efficiency and reduce administrative burdens.
• A three-month public consultation was conducted in 2005, with a dedicated one-month consultation on securitisation and CIUs.
• The CEBS Secretariat may provide logistical support for joint processes.
• The final decision on ECAI recognition is made by each competent authority, based on the joint assessment and other relevant information.

Conclusion

These guidelines aim to ensure a consistent, transparent, and efficient recognition process for ECAIs across the EU. By promoting a common understanding and joint assessment, they support the single market and reduce regulatory arbitrage. The focus is on aligning the mapping of credit assessments to the CRD’s credit quality steps, using a flexible yet objective approach, and enhancing cooperation among supervisory authorities.