2014年-世界发展银行全球_Social_Safety_Nets_and_Gender___Learning_from_Impact_Evaluations_and_World_Bank_Projects_98页_2mb

报告摘要

Social Safety Nets and Gender: Summary

Core Content

This report by the Independent Evaluation Group (IEG) of the World Bank Group provides a systematic review of the impact of Social Safety Net (SSN) interventions on gender outcomes, based on impact evaluations and World Bank-supported projects. It explores how SSNs, which are primarily designed to reduce poverty, can also influence gender dynamics, including women's bargaining power, decision-making, and empowerment.

Main Goals and Objectives

Main Goal: To analyze the gender-specific impacts of SSN interventions, particularly on education, health, employment, and domestic violence.
Objective: To evaluate how SSNs affect different genders and to identify opportunities for improving gender integration in World Bank projects.

Key Findings

1. Gender-Specific Outcomes

SSN interventions can have distinct impacts on men and women, depending on the context and the design of the program.
Education: CCTs (Conditional Cash Transfers) and UCTs (Unconditional Cash Transfers) have shown positive impacts on school attendance, especially for girls. In countries with lower baseline education levels, the gains were more significant.
Child Labor: CCTs reduce child labor by making education less costly and more valuable relative to work. Girls are more likely to combine school with domestic work, which may be more compatible with education.
Employment: Public Works (PW) programs provide temporary employment and may increase employability. Female quotas and women-friendly working conditions help facilitate participation, but the necessity of such quotas is not clearly established.
Health and Nutrition: SSNs have a positive impact on children's anthropometric measures, and CCTs are effective in increasing prenatal care and skilled birth attendance. However, gender differences in these outcomes are not consistently observed.
Domestic Violence: SSN transfers are associated with a reduction in domestic violence, especially when they improve financial stability and reduce household stress. However, the causal link between empowerment and reduced violence is not always clear.

2. Gender Integration in World Bank Projects

Gender is often missing from monitoring and evaluation (M&E) frameworks, with limited discussion of intrahousehold dynamics and the gender context of interventions.
Most projects target women as a vulnerable group or use them instrumentally without addressing the potential costs to them.
The World Bank's Social Protection and Labor (SPL) strategy includes gender considerations, but implementation remains inconsistent.

Methodology and Scope

The analysis is based on 145 impact evaluations (IEs) and 112 World Bank-supported projects.
IEs were selected based on rigorous methodology, including experimental or quasi-experimental designs, and the inclusion of gender-disaggregated outcomes.
Development policy loans were also analyzed, but gender information was limited.

Emerging Trends

SSN interventions are increasingly incorporating gender considerations, especially in project design and targeting.
There is a growing recognition of the importance of understanding how SSNs influence gender dynamics, including bargaining power and decision-making.
More attention is needed to explore the long-term impacts of SSNs on empowerment and fertility.

Challenges and Opportunities

Challenges:
- Limited integration of gender into project design and M&E.
- Inconsistent gender-disaggregated reporting in impact evaluations.
- The need for more comprehensive and nuanced indicators of empowerment.
Opportunities:
- Strengthening the design of SSN interventions to account for gender differences.
- Improving M&E frameworks to better capture gender-specific outcomes.
- Increasing the use of gender-relevant indicators in impact evaluations.

Conclusion

SSN interventions can significantly impact gender outcomes, but their design and implementation must consider the specific roles, responsibilities, and constraints of men and women.
The report highlights the importance of using gender-sensitive frameworks and indicators to fully understand and enhance the effectiveness of SSNs in promoting gender equality and reducing poverty.

References and Appendices

The report includes a list of abbreviations, appendices with methodology, search strategy, coding approach, and a list of projects and impact evaluations.
Additional resources are available online at https://ieg.worldbankgroup.org/evaluations/social-safety-nets-and-gender.

Summary of Key Tables and Figures

Table 2.1: Indicators of Bargaining Power.
Table 2.2: Number of Impact Evaluations by Intervention and Outcome.
Table 2.3: Gender Screening Results and Quality Screening by Intervention.
Table 2.4: Evaluation Methods Used in Impact Evaluations.
Table 3.1: Organization of Findings from Impact Evaluations.
Table 4.1: Gender-Relevant Project Development Objectives Indicators by Intervention.
Table 4.2: Gender in Project Development Objectives Indicators.
Table 4.3: Female Quotas in Public Works Projects.
Figure 2.1: Portfolio Composition by Intervention, Instrument, and Region.
Figure 2.2: Instruments by Region and Fiscal Year.
Figure 2.3: Quantity of Evidence by Intervention, Region, and Type of Program.
Figure 2.4: Number of Impact Evaluations by Length of Treatment.
Figure 3.1: Impact of Institutional Delivery and Skilled Birth Attendance.
Figure 3.2: Impact of Cash Transfer on School Attendance in Latin America.
Figure 3.3: Impact of Cash Transfer on School Attendance in Africa and Asia.
Figure 3.4: Impact of Cash Transfer on Child Labor.
Figure 3.5: Impact of Social Safety Nets on Children's Anthropometric Measures.
Figure 4.1: Female Quotas in Public Works Projects.

Boxes

BOX 2.1: Models of Intra-Household Allocation of Resources.
BOX 2.2: Defining Empowerment.
BOX 4.1: Gender in the World Bank Group Social Protection and Labor Strategy.
BOX 4.2: Gender Considerations in Development Policy Loans.
BOX 4.3: Gender in Public Works.

展开完整摘要