20180427-法国巴黎银行-South_African_labour__A_disturbance_in_the_force_9页_413kb

South African Labour: A Disturbance in the Force

Core Content Summary

This document provides an analysis of the current state of labour unrest in South Africa, highlighting the complex interplay of political and economic factors. The situation is described as volatile and unpredictable due to a combination of legislative changes, wage disputes, and a fragmented union landscape.

Key Points

• Labour Unrest and Strike Season:
  South Africa is experiencing a resurgence of strike activity, commonly referred to as "strike season." This is due to the renewal of short-term wage agreements, which typically occur around this time of year. The current environment, however, is more volatile than usual, influenced by shifting political dynamics and the broader economic context.

• National Strike over Labour Market Changes:
  A national strike was initiated by the South African Federation of Trade Unions (SAFTU), which represents a significant portion of the country’s working population. The strike is in response to proposed changes to the Labour Relations Act and concerns over the level of the national minimum wage. The strike has already impacted transport systems, with alternative forms of transport struggling to meet demand.

• Public-Sector Wage Negotiations:
  The public-sector wage negotiations are at a critical stage, with tensions rising between unions and the government. The Public Servants Association (PSA), the second-largest union in the sector, has formally declared a dispute, while other unions, such as the South African Democratic Teachers Union (SADTU) and the National Education, Health and Allied Workers' Union (NEHAU), appear to be waiting for a behind-the-scenes agreement. Despite this, a full-scale public-sector strike is still considered unlikely, but the situation remains fragile.

• Political and Economic Context:
  The government's attempts to reform the labour market have sparked discontent within the African National Congress (ANC), particularly with President Cyril Ramaphosa. His efforts to make the labour market more globally competitive have been met with resistance, especially from within the ANC. The document suggests that Ramaphosa's political survival may depend on managing these tensions and delivering economic growth before the next national elections.

• Labour Market Trends:
  Several long-term trends are exacerbating the current situation, including a decline in trade union density, the recent increase in VAT, and historically weak economic growth. These factors are putting pressure on both employers and unions, limiting the government’s flexibility and increasing the likelihood of industrial action.

• Potential for Resolution:
  There is a possibility of resolving the bus strike soon, as transport unions have shown willingness to moderate their demands. The document notes that a deal is likely to be reached, with wage increases expected to fall within the range of 9.0–9.5%, close to the employers’ offer of 8.0–9.0%.

• Importance of Labour Stability for Investment:
  Labour unrest is identified as a key barrier to investment in South Africa. The coming weeks and months are expected to be crucial, with several key events including the resumption of public-sector wage talks on 3 May, the implementation of the national minimum wage (likely delayed until June), and reforms to the Labour Relations Act (expected around mid-year).

Main Views

• The current strike season is more volatile than usual due to the complex interplay of political and economic factors.
• SAFTU's strike highlights the growing dissatisfaction with proposed labour market reforms and the minimum wage.
• The public-sector wage dispute is a major concern, with the potential for industrial action, though the likelihood of a full-scale strike remains uncertain.
• President Cyril Ramaphosa faces a difficult balancing act between reforming the labour market and maintaining political support within the ANC.
• A resolution to the bus strike is expected soon, with unions showing a willingness to compromise.
• Secular trends such as declining union density and poor economic growth are contributing to the instability in the labour market.

Critical Events to Monitor

• 3 May: Resumption of public-sector wage talks.
• June: Implementation of the national minimum wage (likely delayed).
• Mid-Year: Expected changes to the Labour Relations Act.
• June/July: Wage negotiations in the gold sector.

Conclusion

The South African labour market is at a crossroads, with multiple disputes and legislative changes creating a highly unstable environment. The success of the government and the ANC in managing these challenges will be crucial for economic recovery and political stability in the coming year.