浑水做空安踏报告：用“提线木偶”操纵利润-2010.7-106页_4mb

Muddy Waters Research Terms of Use Summary

Core Content

These Terms of Use govern the use of current reports published by Muddy Waters Research and supersede any prior terms for older reports. The reports are produced by Muddy Waters Capital LLC and are for informational purposes only, not investment advice. Users must assume the risk of relying on the information provided.

Main Points

• Disclaimer of Investment Advice:
  The reports are not investment advice. Users must conduct their own research and due diligence before making any investment decisions.

• No Liability for Claims:
  Muddy Waters Research and Muddy Waters Capital are not liable for any claims, losses, or damages arising from the use of the information, regardless of negligence.

• Copyright and Distribution:
  Users are prohibited from distributing the information in any form except by linking to the official Muddy Waters Research website.

• Jurisdiction and Governing Law:
  Any disputes arising from the use of the website or its content are governed by the laws of the State of California, and users agree to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of San Francisco courts.

• UK Restrictions:
  The research and materials are issued only to Permitted Recipients under UK law, and non-compliant individuals must not act or rely on the information.

Key Information

• Muddy Waters Entities:
  Muddy Waters Research and Muddy Waters Capital are separate entities, with the latter being an investment adviser registered with the SEC. They are not registered in other jurisdictions.

• Investment Advisory Relationship:
  Muddy Waters Capital does not provide investment advice unless a written investment adviser-client relationship exists.

• Report Ownership:
  Each report is the property of the applicable Muddy Waters Entity and is not attributable to any Muddy Waters Related Persons, except where stated.

• Report Usage and Risk:
  Users agree to hold harmless Muddy Waters Research, Muddy Waters Capital, and their affiliates for any losses incurred from the use of the reports.

• Time Limit for Claims:
  Any claim or cause of action related to the website or its content must be filed within one year of the alleged harm, or it will be forever barred.

Summary of the ANTA Report

Overview of the Report

This report, titled "ANTA Part I: Turds in the Punchbowl", is the first in a series that alleges widespread fraud at ANTA Sports Products Ltd. (ticker: 2020.HK), a Hong Kong-listed sports apparel company.

Key Findings

• Financial Fraud Allegations:
  Muddy Waters Research alleges that ANTA inflates its reported revenues and reduces expenses by secretly controlling its Tier 1 distributors. These distributors are used to manipulate financial statements.

• Secret Control of Distributors:
  ANTA is accused of using proxy owners to maintain control over its distributors, which are referred to as "subsidiaries" or "branch companies" in internal communications.

• Evidence of Control:

  • ANTA controls approximately 27 distributors, at least 25 of which are Tier 1.
  • These distributors account for about 70% of ANTA brand sales.
  • ANTA's senior executives, including Wu Yonghua, are known to have direct control over the distributors through personnel and financial management.

• Interview Excerpts:

  • Mr. A: Confirms that ANTA has a controlling stake in its distributors and that they are referred to as subsidiaries.
  • Mr. B: States that most of the 51 customers are subsidiaries, with a minority being independent distributors.
  • Mr. C: Details the relationships between ANTA executives and the proxy owners, including Lin Sankuang, Lin Xiaokuang, and Su Weiqing.
  • Mr. D: Explains the historical relationship between ANTA and its distributors, including financial support and control.
  • Mr. E: Confirms that the financial department of Guangzhou Anda is managed by ANTA's headquarters.

Evidence of Control

• Jinjiang Yundong Business Consulting Co. Ltd. (Yundong):

  • Yundong is an arm of ANTA, with ANTA executives Li Dan and Wang Huayou holding key roles.
  • Yundong is accused of controlling 27 distributors, with 25 being Tier 1.
  • The company is located in ANTA's Jinjiang industrial park, and its recruiter uses an ANTA.cn email address.

• Distributor List:
  The report includes a list of 27 distributors, with at least 25 being Tier 1. These include companies such as Beijing Jiyuan, Zhengzhou Anfa, Jinan Ruili, and Guangzhou Anda.

• Financial Performance of Distributors:

  • The 2017 COGS of these distributors totaled approximately RMB 5.5 billion, which is roughly one-third of ANTA's total revenue.
  • Gross margins for these distributors range from 7% to 8%, and net margins are close to zero, suggesting that ANTA is using them to inflate its own financials.

Conclusion

The report concludes that ANTA's financial performance is artificially inflated through the control of its distributors. The company's operating margins are not a result of superior operations but rather due to financial manipulation. The report urges investors to conduct their own due diligence and not rely solely on the information provided.