2005-12-11-皮尤-EXTRA_EXTRA_19页_186kb

Analysis Summary of the Report

This report from the Project for Excellence in Journalism compares new youth-oriented tabloids with traditional broadsheets, examining their content and implications for the future of print media. The study analyzes seven newspapers from Boston, Washington D.C., and Dallas over a 10-day period, coding 2,321 stories.

Key Differences Between Tabloids and Broadsheets

• Story Length and Style: Youth-oriented tabloids feature shorter, snappier stories averaging 7,000 words per issue, with 68% of stories 250 words or less. Broadsheets have longer, more in-depth articles (89% exceed 500 words), emphasizing thorough reporting.
• Content and Coverage: Tabloids cover a broader range of topics including celebrities, entertainment, and lifestyle, offering quick summaries. However, they rely heavily on wire copy (72% of stories), with sparse local focus (22% vs. 53% of broadsheets). Broadsheets provide more original reporting and depth but have less breadth.
• Sourcing and Perspective: Tabloids cite sources infrequently (44% of stories have multiple sources vs. 94% of broadsheets). They often present one-sided or fact-only narratives (74% of controversial stories offer only one viewpoint), lacking context and future implications.

Audience Reach

• The term "tabloid" is evolving to include both youth-focused papers and independent ones like the Washington Examiner.
• Young readers are a minor focus: 16% of tabloid stories highlight individuals aged 18-35, primarily celebrities. Tabloids struggle to connect stories to broader youth relevance, despite some design changes.
• Distribution channels partly explain demographic skew, as tabs are often sold at subways, drawing younger readers unintentionally.

Future Implications

• Newspapers may need to blend tabloid's broad coverage with broadsheet's depth to efficiently cover news with fewer resources.
• However, tabloids primarily trim wire copy rather than innovate on content for younger audiences, limiting their potential to revitalize print media.
• Overall, tabloids fill a niche for quick news but fail to replace the depth of broadsheets.

This study suggests a caution against simplistic solutions in journalism, emphasizing the need for traditional newspapers to experiment with format and content beyond surface-level changes.