EBA欧洲银行-Slides-Session-2-Lea-Zicchino-28Prometeia29_33页_1mb

Summary of "European banks in the 21st century – are their business models sustainable?"

Core Content

This paper analyzes the sustainability of European banks' business models (BBMs) in the context of financial regulation and supervision. It explores the performance of three main business models—Retail, Investment, and Diversified banks—using a dataset of 77 European banks, covering the period from 2006 to 2015. The study employs both deterministic and probabilistic clustering methods to identify peer groups and assess the impact of macroeconomic and financial factors on bank performance.

Main Views

• Business Model Identification: The authors use Supervised and Unsupervised Learning techniques to identify three distinct BBMs: Retail, Investment, and Diversified.
• Peer Group Classification: Banks are classified into peer groups based on their business model and characteristics such as systemic relevance, cross-border activity, and complexity.
• Performance Analysis: The study evaluates the relative performance of different BBMs and peer groups using panel data regressions, controlling for country-specific and bank-specific factors.

Key Information

Dataset and Methodology

• The dataset includes 77 banking groups from 14 Euro Area countries and 4 UK banks, representing around 80% of the EMU's total banking assets.
• Deterministic Clustering: Uses Ward's method and Euclidean distance to group banks based on balance sheet indicators.
• Probabilistic Clustering: Applies the Fuzzy C-Means algorithm to estimate the probability distribution of banks belonging to a specific BBM.
• Peer Group Identification: Based on criteria such as systemic relevance, cross-border exposure, business complexity, and specialization.

Business Models and Peer Groups

• Retail Banks: Dominant in Italy, with some internationalized retail banks showing higher profitability in 2014-2015.
• Investment Banks: Showed better performance before the financial crisis but were less profitable after 2010.
• Diversified Banks: Include a mix of business lines and showed mixed performance.
• Macro Drivers: Economic growth, yield curve, and sovereign default risk are key factors for Retail banks' profitability.
• Bank-Specific Drivers: Credit quality is the main factor influencing Return on Assets (RoA).
• Capital and Risk: Banks with higher capital levels may benefit from better performance.

Performance Analysis

• Profitability Trends: Retail banks were the best performers before the Sovereign Debt Crisis, but after 2010, their business strategies had minimal impact on profitability.
• Country Factors: After 2010, profitability differences across BBMs were largely explained by country-specific factors such as economic growth.
• KPI Analysis: Retail banks experienced a significant decline in performance during the crisis, while internationalized retail banks showed resilience.
• Cost Analysis: Operating costs of banks are not significantly influenced by macroeconomic risk factors.

Key Findings

• Credit Quality and Yield Curve: There is a counterintuitive relationship between credit quality and the yield curve, suggesting that banks may benefit from higher yields even with higher credit risk.
• Capital Adequacy: Holding more capital appears to be beneficial for banks.
• Model Validation: Further research is needed to validate the peer group classification using alternative machine learning algorithms.

Open Issues for Further Research

• Model Validation: Testing the peer group classification with alternative supervised learning algorithms.
• Forecasting: Developing a forecasting tool to assess banks' ability to maintain profitability under different macroeconomic and financial market conditions.

Methodological Applications

• Benchmarking: The methodology can be used for benchmarking and performance assessment of banks against their peers.
• Viability Assessment: Evaluating the viability of different business models in varying macroeconomic and financial environments.

Conclusion

The study concludes that while the business models of European banks have evolved, their relative performance is increasingly influenced by macroeconomic factors rather than internal strategies. This suggests that regulatory frameworks should consider the broader economic context when assessing bank sustainability.