20140219-Maybank_KERPL-Consensus_too_bullish__Stay_at_HOLD_12页_383kb

Sunny Optical (2382 HK) Summary

Core Content

Sunny Optical (2382 HK) is a Hong Kong-listed company in the technology sector. The current share price is HKD6.39, with a target price of HKD7.00 (+10%). The market capitalization is USD875M, and the average daily trading volume (ADTV) is USD5M. The company's performance has been underwhelming, with a 17% underperformance against the Hang Seng Index (HSI) since mid-January 2014.

Main Points

• Earnings Revision: The company's FY13-14F earnings have been cut by 9% and 10% respectively, due to growing competition risks.
• Consensus vs. Analysis: The consensus forecasts are deemed too bullish, and the company is maintained at a non-consensus HOLD rating.
• Target Price: The new target price is HKD7, based on a 12x FY14E P/E ratio, which is at the low end of the Street's expectations.
• Share Price Performance: The share price is expected to range trade, with a limited downside even if there are earnings misses.

Key Financial Metrics

Business Breakdown

Top five customers account for 48% of total sales.

Valuation and Risks

• Fair Value: Estimated at HKD6.8, based on normalized ROE of 15.8% and a fair value multiple of 1.37.
• Implied P/E: 11.5x for FY14F.
• Upside Risks:
  • Stronger-than-expected handset demand, especially from Chinese brands and mid-to-high-end segment.
  • Less ASP erosion due to slower yield-rate improvement or capacity expansion by competitors.
  • Market-share gain from key customers.
• Downside Risks:
  • Weaker-than-expected handset demand.
  • Severe ASP erosion due to competition or faster yield-rate improvements.
  • Market-share loss from key customers.

Outlook and Analysis

• FY14 Forecast: Sales and EPS are expected to rise by 19% and 18.4% YoY, driven by increasing Chinese smartphone demand and camera megapixel migration.
• Net Profit Forecast: 16% lower than consensus due to concerns over price erosion in the camera module business.
• Price Competition: The report highlights that price competition in the camera lens business is relatively mild due to more rational capacity expansion.
• Margin Trends: Gross margin is estimated at 16.4% for FY14F, slightly lower than the previous year. Operating and net margins are also slightly reduced.

Summary of Key Insights

• Sunny Optical faces significant competition in the camera module business, which is expected to lead to price erosion.
• The company's share price is likely to range trade due to the limited downside.
• The company's target price is set at HKD7, reflecting a 12x P/E multiple and fair value estimates.
• The report highlights the importance of the camera feature in smartphones and the potential for OEMs to continue investing in higher-resolution cameras.
• The company's fair value is estimated at HKD6.8, and its financial model shows a gradual decline in profitability ratios and growth rates over the forecast period.

Conclusion

Despite positive catalysts such as new customer wins and growth in the automotive lens business, Sunny Optical is maintained at a HOLD rating due to the high risk of price erosion and aggressive competition. The report suggests that the Street's consensus forecasts may need to be revised down, as the company's performance is expected to lag behind. The fair value calculation and financial metrics indicate that the company may be undervalued, but the risks associated with the industry and the company's exposure to price competition may prevent further re-rating.