布鲁盖尔-Can-emerging-markets-be-a-source-of-global-troubles-again__16页_455kb

Summary of the EU-Mercosur Free Trade Agreement: Prospects and Risks

Core Content

The EU-Mercosur Free Trade Agreement (FTA) is a significant trade deal between the European Union and the Mercosur bloc, consisting of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, and Uruguay. The agreement was finalized in June 2019 after nearly two decades of negotiations and is expected to have both measurable and non-measurable economic impacts.

The FTA aims to reduce tariffs and improve trade relations, but its scope is relatively modest, especially in agriculture and manufacturing. While the quantifiable gains are small due to the limited size of trade flows and the modest liberalization of sensitive products, the potential for long-term productivity improvements and structural reforms is substantial.

Main Points and Key Information

1. Ratification Process and Political Risks

• The FTA faces a challenging ratification process, particularly in Argentina, where a shift in government could affect the outcome.
• Brazil's Bolsonaro administration supports the agreement, but Mercosur as a whole is politically unstable.
• EU member states' parliaments will also have a say in ratification, given the broader Association Agreement context.
• Environmental and agricultural interests may oppose the agreement in some EU countries, such as France.

2. Trade Flows and Tariff Reductions

• EU exports to Mercosur total $48.6 billion annually, representing 2% of extra-EU exports and 0.26% of EU GDP.
• Mercosur exports to the EU amount to $43.7 billion, or 1.8% of Mercosur GDP.
• Trade with the EU is not the most significant for Mercosur, as China has become a more important export destination.
• Tariffs on EU imports from Mercosur are around 13% for agriculture and 10% for non-agriculture, while Mercosur's tariffs on EU goods are much lower, around 1%.

3. Quantifiable Gains from the Agreement

• The FTA eliminates tariffs on 100% of industrial goods from Mercosur and 90% of industrial goods from the EU.
• In agriculture, the EU removes tariffs on 82% of Mercosur products, while Mercosur removes tariffs on 93% of EU agricultural products.
• The quantifiable gains are estimated to be small, with EU gains at 0.026% of GDP and Mercosur gains at 0.6% of GDP.
• The absolute gains for the EU are larger due to higher tariff payments to Mercosur.

4. Dynamic Gains and Long-Term Impacts

• Dynamic gains, such as increased productivity and innovation, are expected if the agreement leads to more competition and resource reallocation.
• Studies suggest that full liberalization could result in GDP increases of up to 0.34% for the EU and over 4% for Argentina, with Brazil gaining nearly 3%.
• However, the current FTA is limited in scope and does not fully liberalize sensitive products or address EU agricultural subsidies.

5. Environmental and Reform Considerations

• The agreement includes environmental commitments, especially related to deforestation in the Amazon, and incorporates civil-society monitoring.
• The EU is seen as a stabilizing force in the global trading system, and the FTA reinforces its commitment to multilateralism.
• The agreement may serve as an insurance policy against the collapse of the World Trade Organization (WTO) framework.

6. Comparison with Previous Offers

• The FTA is more liberal than the 2004 EU offer but less than the 2006 Mercosur offer.
• The EU's agricultural concessions are limited, and Mercosur's liberalization of goods is partial.
• The agreement includes provisions for tariff-rate quotas (TRQs) for certain agricultural products, such as beef, cheese, and sugar, but these TRQs are relatively small compared to EU consumption.

7. Domestic Reforms and Implementation

• The agreement's success depends heavily on domestic reforms in both the EU and Mercosur.
• The EU must improve the competitiveness of its farmers and reduce trade barriers, while Mercosur must implement structural reforms to enhance productivity and innovation.
• Effective implementation is crucial for the agreement to deliver its promised benefits.

Conclusion

Despite its modest quantifiable gains, the EU-Mercosur FTA is a landmark agreement with significant implications for both regions. It represents a shift towards more open trade and could drive structural reforms in Mercosur and agricultural modernization in the EU. However, its success hinges on political stability, environmental compliance, and the ability of both blocs to implement necessary domestic reforms.