20140908-NATIXIS-Can_France_find_the_solution_to_its_problems_abroad__11页_329kb

Summary of FLASH ECONOMICS Document No. 641 (8 September 2014)

Core Content

This document, authored by Patrick Artus, analyzes the structural causes of France's weak economic growth and evaluates the potential for external factors to stimulate recovery. It concludes that France should not rely on foreign developments to solve its economic problems but must focus on internal structural reforms.

Main Points

1. France's Growth Outlook

• France is expected to experience very weak growth in 2014 and abnormally weak growth in 2015.
• The document emphasizes that the lack of growth is due to structural issues rather than temporary shocks.

2. Structural Causes of Weak Growth

• Household and corporate deleveraging: Continued reduction in private sector lending (Chart 2) indicates ongoing financial restraint.
• Low corporate profitability and return on capital: This discourages investment and employment (Charts 3A and B, Chart 4).
• High production costs: Despite the level of sophistication in French production, these costs are excessively high (Chart 5).
• High unskilled labor costs: This contributes to high unskilled unemployment (Table 1).
• Insufficient labor force skills: France ranks lower than several European countries in terms of labor skills (Table 2).

3. Key Recommendations for Domestic Policies

• Wage formation reform: To restore profitability and competitiveness (Chart 6, Chart 7).
• Alternative poverty reduction strategies: Avoid reliance on high minimum wage (Chart 8).
• Reduction in non-productive government spending and tax burden: To improve economic efficiency (Charts 9A and 9B).
• Education and vocational training reform: To enhance workforce skills and competitiveness.

4. External Factors and Their Limitations

• Global recovery: Expected to be weak due to:
  • Sluggish U.S. wage growth and housing market stagnation (Charts 11A and 11B).
  • Slow growth in large emerging economies (Brazil, India, Turkey, South Africa, Russia) due to structural issues (Charts 12A, 12B, 13A, 13B, 14, 16).
  • Lack of economic recovery in the Eurozone (Chart 15).
• Stimulus in Germany: The French government has called for German demand stimulation, but:
  • German companies are already facing declining profitability and competitiveness due to wage growth outpacing productivity (Charts 21A and 21B).
  • Germany's aging population and immigration trends lead to a preference for asset accumulation over debt, making fiscal stimulus unlikely (Charts 22A and 22B).
• Euro depreciation: A weaker euro could boost exports, but:
  • It would also increase import prices, especially for commodities (Charts 23, 27, 28).
  • The Eurozone's external surplus and strong demand for its bonds limit the potential for significant depreciation (Chart 29).

Key Information

• The document argues that France's economic stagnation is primarily due to internal structural issues.
• External factors such as global recovery, German stimulus, and euro depreciation are unlikely to provide a substantial boost to the French economy.
• The author stresses that structural reforms within France are the only viable path to economic recovery.

Conclusion

• The document concludes that France should not wait for external factors to drive growth but must implement domestic reforms to address the root causes of its economic stagnation.
• These reforms include changes in wage formation, education, taxation, and government spending.

Disclaimer

• The document is confidential and intended solely for the use of the addressee.
• It is prepared by economists and does not constitute independent investment research.
• No liability is accepted by Natixis or its affiliates for any financial loss or decision based on this document.
• The information is based on public data and may be subject to change.
• The document is not a personalized recommendation and does not constitute an offer or solicitation of investment.
• It is subject to legal restrictions in certain jurisdictions and should not be distributed without prior consent.