卡内基国际和平基金会-G20-Must-Help-Manage-Eurozone-Crisis_9页_197kb

G20 and Global Economic and Financial Risks Summary

Core Content

Dr. Uri Dadush, Director of the International Economics Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, testifies before the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs about the G20's role in addressing global economic and financial risks, particularly the Euro crisis and the need for sustainable growth. He emphasizes the importance of the G20 in coordinating international responses and reforming global economic institutions.

Main Issues Addressed

1. G20's Role in the Euro Crisis

• Moral Suasion: The G20 can exert moral pressure on Eurozone countries to take more decisive action.
• Financial Implications: A bailout for Spain and Italy would require about $2.1 trillion in loans, far exceeding the capacity of existing mechanisms like the IMF and EFSF.
• European Institutional Weakness: The Eurozone lacks a strong fiscal and political union, and the ECB is legally restricted from supporting member nations.
• Global Impact: A Eurozone collapse would have severe repercussions on the U.S. and emerging markets due to trade and financial linkages.
• IMF Expansion: To support the Eurozone, the IMF's resources would need to be expanded by $1 trillion, with the U.S. contributing $177 billion.
• Conditions for Support: The G20 should push for strict conditions on both recipient and core countries, as well as the ECB, to ensure sustainability and reform.

2. Restarting Sustainable Economic Growth

• Focus on Domestic Policies: Economic growth is primarily driven by domestic policies rather than trade balances.
• Structural Reforms: Emphasis should be placed on structural reforms such as privatization, market liberalization, and R&D promotion, rather than just macroeconomic management.
• U.S. Leadership: The U.S. needs to take a stronger leadership role in promoting structural reforms within the G20, especially in areas like trade and fiscal policy.
• WTO and Doha Round: The failure of the Doha Round highlights the need for WTO reform. A plurilateral approach to trade negotiations could help break the stalemate.
• Trade Facilitation: Supporting trade facilitation and other elements of the Doha draft can help restore global trade momentum.

3. G20's Long-Term Role and Success Factors

• Steering Committee Function: The G20 should act as a steering committee, focusing on systemic global policy issues rather than being a decision-making body.
• Realism in Expectations: The G20 must be realistic about its capabilities and avoid overpromising. It cannot enforce policies but can build consensus.
• Emerging Economies' Inclusion: While emerging economies should be included in the G20, they must also take on their responsibilities. The G20 should provide them with time to articulate clear policy goals.
• Structure and Continuity: A permanent secretariat and a more durable presidency could improve continuity, but there are risks of bureaucratization and mission creep.
• U.S. Leadership: The U.S. remains the most important leader in the G20, especially in relation to China. Leadership through example is key.

Key Information

• Eurozone Bailout Costs: $2.1 trillion, with the IMF potentially contributing $700 billion.
• U.S. Exposure to Eurozone: $850 billion in direct exposure and $1.8 trillion in indirect exposure.
• Doha Round Failure: Highlights the need for WTO reform and plurilateral negotiations.
• Structural Reforms Needed: Include tax and expenditure reforms, labor market flexibility, and market liberalization.
• G20's Limitations: It lacks enforcement power and cannot replace established multilateral institutions like the IMF or WTO.

Conclusion

The G20 must focus on systemic global economic challenges, promote structural reforms, and maintain a clear, realistic agenda. Its success depends on strong leadership, particularly from the U.S., and on its ability to function effectively without overextending itself. The U.S. should lead by example and work closely with emerging economies like China to ensure the G20 remains a relevant and effective forum for global economic governance.