英文_OECD_监管沙盒工具包_监管机构有效建立和管理监管沙盒的综合指南_55页_1mb

Regulatory Sandbox Toolkit Summary

Core Content

The Regulatory Sandbox Toolkit is a comprehensive guide for regulators to establish and manage regulatory sandboxes effectively. It was developed as part of a project in Croatia, supported by the European Union through the Technical Support Instrument and implemented by the OECD in collaboration with the European Commission. The toolkit aims to help regulators create controlled environments where new financial products, services, or business models can be tested under relaxed regulatory conditions, but with oversight.

Main Purpose

The primary objective of the toolkit is to assist regulators in setting up and managing regulatory sandboxes that promote innovation while ensuring consumer protection, market integrity, and regulatory learning. It is aligned with the OECD’s recommendations on agile regulatory governance and anticipatory governance of emerging technologies.

Key Components of the Toolkit

The toolkit is structured into three main components:

1. Regulatory Sandbox Guidebook (RS Guidebook)
   This guidebook outlines the three main phases of a regulatory sandbox:

   • Planning and designing
   • Executing
   • Closing and learning from
     It includes key steps such as stakeholder engagement, risk management, regulatory flexibility, and performance measurement. Before starting the sandbox process, regulators are advised to use the "Sandbox Test" (Annex A) to determine if a sandbox is the appropriate tool.

2. Regulatory Sandbox Workbook (RS Workbook)
   A practical, fillable step-by-step guide for documenting and structuring sandbox initiatives. It includes:

   • Legality Test and Suitability Test to assess feasibility and benefits
   • Blueprints or canvases for each sandbox phase
   • Tools for defining objectives, identifying stakeholders, assessing risks, and determining resources

3. Instructions on Filling out the RS Workbook
   This component provides detailed guidance on completing the RS Workbook, ensuring consistency and clarity in the sandbox process. It outlines steps for drafting the sandbox application, mapping stakeholders, setting up data collection, and developing an evaluation strategy.

Main Views and Recommendations

• Regulatory sandboxes are an important instrument for regulatory experimentation, offering a controlled environment for testing new technologies and business models.
• They help balance innovation with consumer protection and market stability by allowing limited regulatory flexibility while maintaining oversight.
• The toolkit promotes forward-looking governance, helping regulators anticipate and monitor the implications of high-impact innovations.
• It encourages outcome-focused regulatory approaches, supporting structured and safe innovation testing.

Key Steps in the Sandbox Process

Step 1: Planning and designing the sandbox

• Application process design: Define eligibility criteria and provide information and support to potential applicants.
• Prototyping the sandbox: Develop an initial design proposal based on stakeholder needs, learning from other sandbox implementations, and defining the sandbox’s aims, objectives, and parameters.
• Consulting on the sandbox design: Engage with a broad range of stakeholders, including industry, innovators, and the public, to validate and enrich the sandbox design. This includes defining the scope, focus, and governance framework.

Step 2: Executing the sandbox

• Designing a testing plan: Outline what will be tested, how, and why. Include standard elements such as the scope, methodology, participation and accountability, data management, risk management, KPIs, and communication strategy.
• Legal document development: Create a formal legal agreement or contract that outlines the terms of the sandbox, including time periods, responsibilities, data collection, KPIs, and check-in frequencies.
• Implementation: Conduct the sandbox test in real or realistic conditions, either virtually or in practice. The test is designed to allow regulators to observe the impact of the innovation and draw conclusions.

Step 3: Closing and learning from the sandbox

• Evaluation: Use the insights gained from the sandbox to inform future regulatory decisions and policy development.
• Reporting and dissemination: Share findings with participants and other impacted stakeholders, including other regulators and policymakers.
• Exit options: Determine the appropriate exit strategy based on the outcomes of the sandbox, such as full regulatory approval, partial changes, or termination due to risks.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

• Regulatory experimentation clauses are crucial for ensuring the legality of sandbox activities. These clauses provide temporary exemptions from current legal rules.
• The toolkit includes Annex B, which offers guidance on formulating such experimentation clauses and lists examples from various countries and sectors.
• Data management is a key focus, with emphasis on quality, security, and transparency. The toolkit provides criteria and processes for data collection, validation, and storage.
• Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) and fundamental rights (e.g., privacy, data protection, anti-discrimination) must be clearly defined and respected in the sandbox environment.

Conclusion

The Regulatory Sandbox Toolkit is a valuable resource for regulators aiming to foster innovation through a structured and supervised experimental environment. It provides a clear framework for planning, executing, and closing regulatory sandboxes, while also addressing legal, ethical, and practical considerations. The toolkit supports both innovators and regulators in navigating the complex landscape of emerging technologies and evolving regulatory needs.

Additional Information

• The toolkit is available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence.
• It draws on OECD recommendations and aligns with the OECD Framework for Anticipatory Governance of Emerging Technologies.
• It includes Annexes that provide detailed guidance on the "Sandbox Test", legal bases for experimentation, and data management processes.