2005年-世界发展银行全球_Output-Based_Aid___Supporting_Infrastructure_Delivery_Through_Explicit_and_Performance-Based_Subsidies_4页_890kb

OBA Approaches Summary

Core Content

Output-Based Aid (OBA) is a strategy designed to improve the effectiveness of aid by linking subsidies directly to the delivery of specific infrastructure and social services. This approach is particularly useful in situations where user charges alone cannot cover the costs of service delivery, especially for disadvantaged groups or in areas with public good characteristics.

OBA is a policy tool that supports the delivery of essential services such as water, sanitation, electricity, transport, telecommunications, education, and health care. It aims to ensure that aid is used efficiently, transparently, and with accountability, by shifting performance risk to service providers and ensuring that subsidies are targeted effectively.

Main Views

• Explicit and Performance-Based Subsidies: OBA subsidies are explicit in terms of their purpose, recipients, and financial components. They are performance-based, meaning payments are tied to the successful delivery of services.
• Improving Aid Effectiveness: OBA enhances aid effectiveness by increasing accountability, transparency, value for money, and reducing economic distortions.
• Public-Private Partnership (PPP): OBA serves as a mechanism to implement PPP, leveraging private capital and efficiencies to improve service delivery to the poor.
• Targeting Subsidies: Targeting subsidies to the poorest households or communities is crucial, though it can be challenging due to cost and complexity. However, it is more effective than implicit subsidies.
• Subsidy Design: The design of subsidies must be appropriate for the situation, whether one-time, transitional, or ongoing, to ensure they support service delivery without creating market distortions.

Key Information

Subsidy Types

• One-time Subsidy: To support initial connection costs.
• Transitional Subsidy: To ease the transition to full cost recovery.
• Ongoing Subsidy: To support lifeline tariffs for essential services.

Design Principles

• Intelligent Subsidy Design: Ensure subsidies reach the intended beneficiaries, are appropriately sized, and do not hinder long-term development.
• Performance Regime: Link subsidies to specific outputs and use competitive mechanisms or performance-based contracts to incentivize service providers.
• Competitive Dynamic: Introduce competition among service providers to improve efficiency and value for money. This can include bidding for minimum subsidies or using a "Swiss challenge" approach.
• Risk Mitigation: Address payment risks by ensuring reliable disbursement of funds and using mechanisms like escrow accounts or credit guarantees.

Examples of OBA Implementation

• Cambodia Water Project: Subsidies were directly targeted to poor households, with local communities involved in identifying eligible recipients.
• Paraguay Water Project: Subsidies were directed to unserved rural areas, with the poorest customers contributing labor as part of their payment.
• Peru Telecommunications Project: Used a least-subsidy bidding approach, resulting in significant investment mobilization and lower subsidy requests.

Challenges

• Implementation Complexity: OBA requires careful planning and monitoring to ensure effective delivery.
• Political and Economic Constraints: In some cases, it may not be feasible to introduce competition, especially in areas where only one provider exists.
• Limited Evidence: While initial results are promising, more projects are needed to fully evaluate the effectiveness of OBA.

Conclusion

OBA is a promising approach to improving aid effectiveness in infrastructure delivery. It encourages better governance, accountability, and efficiency by linking subsidies to measurable outputs. However, its success depends on proper design, implementation, and monitoring. GPOBA plays a key role in supporting the development and documentation of OBA projects, helping to promote sustainable service delivery to the poor.

References

• Cannock, Geoffrey. 2001. "Expanding Rural Telephony: Output-Based Contracts for Pay Phones in Peru."
• Mumssen, Yogita. 2004. "Output-based Aid in Cambodia: Private operators and local communities help deliver water to the poor."
• Drees, Franz, Jordan Schwartz, and Alexander Bakalian. 2004. "Output-based Aid in Water: Lessons in Implementation from a Pilot in Paraguay."

About GPOBA

The Global Partnership on Output-Based Aid (GPOBA) is a multidonor trust fund managed by the World Bank. Its mission is to fund, demonstrate, and document OBA approaches that support the sustainable delivery of basic services to those who cannot afford them. GPOBA contributes to the development of pilot projects and the dissemination of knowledge on OBA practices.