卡内基国际和平基金会-Counter-Terrorism-from-Within-Assessing-Saudi-Arabia-s-Religious-Rehabilitation-and-Disengagement-Programme_6页_179kb

Saudi Arabia's Religious Rehabilitation and Disengagement Programme

Core Content

The Saudi Arabia Religious Rehabilitation and Disengagement Programme is a comprehensive 'soft' counterterrorism strategy aimed at rehabilitating and disengaging Islamist extremists and militants from violent ideologies. Launched after a series of domestic terrorist attacks in 2003, the programme combines religious education, psychological counseling, and social support to address the ideological underpinnings of extremism.

Main Objectives

• De-radicalisation: To counter the ideological justifications for violent extremism, particularly the doctrine of takfir (declaring others as non-believers).
• Demobilisation: To encourage extremists to renounce violence and return to mainstream Islamic practices.
• Reintegration: To reintegrate former extremists back into society and prevent recidivism.
• Prevention: To stop the spread of extremist ideas within families and communities.

Key Components of the Programme

The programme is structured around three main phases:

1. Prevention: Targeting individuals before they become involved with extremist groups.
2. Rehabilitation: Engaging those already involved in extremist activities to repudiate their beliefs.
3. Aftercare: Ensuring that those who have renounced extremism do not return to violent activities.

The Counseling Programme, managed by the Advisory Committee under the Ministry of Interior, is the primary mechanism for rehabilitation. It includes:

• Religious Subcommittee: Composed of approximately 150 clerics, scholars, and professors, responsible for engaging detainees in dialogue and teaching the state-approved interpretation of Islam.
• Psychological and Social Subcommittee: Includes around 50 psychologists and social scientists who evaluate detainees' mental state, social background, and compliance with the programme.
• Security Subcommittee: Assesses security risks and provides release recommendations based on the evaluations from other subcommittees.
• Media Subcommittee: Produces educational materials for both rehabilitation and prevention efforts, focusing on young Saudi men through platforms like Jumu'ah prayers and mosque events.

Programme Mechanics

• Counseling Process: Begins with listening to detainees and understanding their motivations, followed by religious debate and psychological counseling to challenge their extremist beliefs.
• Long Study Sessions: Six-week courses with up to 20 participants, covering topics such as takfir, walaah, bayat, terrorism, and jihad. Participants must pass an exam to progress.
• Social Support: Extensive support is provided to detainees and their families to prevent further radicalisation and facilitate reintegration into society.
• Monitoring: Graduates are monitored through both overt and covert means to ensure they do not reoffend.

Programme Demographics

• Participants: Mostly young men from lower- and middle-class families, with limited formal religious education.
• Backgrounds: Many participants had prior criminal records, particularly related to drug use, and were influenced by extremist literature, media, and online content.
• Sources of Inspiration: Theoretical texts were more influential for those involved in foreign jihad, while operational leaders and military figures inspired domestic extremists.
• Notable Figures: Both groups were influenced by Osama bin Laden, but domestic extremists were more likely to be motivated by immediate paramilitary concerns, such as expelling foreign forces and seeking revenge.

Success Metrics

• Recidivism Rate: Only 2% of participants who renounced their beliefs and were released were rearrested for security offenses.
• Guantanamo Returnees: 117 individuals repatriated from Guantanamo have not reoffended, indicating the programme's effectiveness.
• Social Factors: Family dynamics, lack of parental oversight, and troubled home environments are linked to radicalisation, but ideology remains the central driver.

Conclusion

The Saudi programme has demonstrated significant success in disengaging extremists from violent ideologies, largely due to its holistic approach combining religious, psychological, and social elements. As the most well-funded and long-running such initiative, it has become a model for other countries, including Western nations like the UK, seeking to implement similar counter-radicalisation strategies. However, the programme is not universally effective, and hardcore extremists remain a challenge.

Notes on Implementation

• The programme is not a form of interrogation but a structured rehabilitation process.
• The focus on authority and legitimacy in Islamic doctrine is central to the government's messaging.
• Co-optation and cultural factors such as family honor and social obligations are used to reinforce the programme's effectiveness.
• The programme is continuously evaluated and adapted based on participant feedback and research findings.