卡内基国际和平基金会-Trump-s-First-Test-in-Asia-Part-II_7页_314kb

CHINA IN THE WORLD PODCAST - Episode 82 Summary

Core Content

This episode of the China in the World podcast, hosted by Paul Haenle and featuring guest Michael Green, discusses the implications of U.S.-China relations in the context of North Korea's nuclear and missile threats, the deployment of the THAAD system in South Korea, and the broader strategic dynamics in the Asia-Pacific region.

Main Takeaways

• North Korea as a Threat: North Korea's missile tests, including a recent series of launches and the assassination of Kim Jong-Nam using VX nerve agent, have intensified regional tensions. These actions are seen as a demonstration of North Korea's willingness to use biological warfare and develop nuclear capabilities.

• U.S. and South Korea's Response: The U.S. and South Korea have begun deploying the THAAD missile defense system in response to North Korea's threats. This move is perceived by the U.S. as a necessary step to protect its allies and citizens.

• China's Opposition to THAAD: China has strongly opposed the THAAD deployment, viewing it as a threat to its strategic interests. Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi called for a freeze on North Korean missile tests in exchange for reduced U.S. military exercises, but this proposal is unlikely to be accepted by the U.S. or South Korea.

• China's Strategy and Miscalculations: China has attempted to use economic pressure to influence South Korea's stance on THAAD, including halting construction projects and limiting tourism. However, this approach is seen as counterproductive and may push South Korea closer to the U.S. and Japan.

• U.S.-China Cooperation on North Korea: Green suggests that immediate cooperation between the U.S. and China is more feasible than a long-term diplomatic solution. He advocates for joint efforts to intercept North Korean shipments and activities related to their nuclear and missile programs, in line with UN Security Council resolutions.

• U.S.-China Summit Expectations: The upcoming meeting between President Trump and President Xi Jinping is expected to be more of a symbolic photo opportunity than a substantive negotiation. Green emphasizes the importance of having trusted advisors from both sides engage in dialogue to build a long-term relationship framework.

• Strategic Dialogue Importance: The Strategic and Economic Dialogue (S&ED) is not seen as the most effective platform for ongoing discussions. Instead, Green suggests focusing on establishing direct communication channels with trusted officials to maintain and improve U.S.-China relations.

Key Information

• THAAD Deployment: The U.S. and South Korea have started deploying the THAAD system in South Korea, which China opposes due to its strategic implications.

• China's Diplomatic Efforts: China's foreign minister, Wang Yi, has called for a freeze on North Korean missile tests, but this is not a viable option for the U.S. or South Korea.

• Economic Pressure: China has used economic tools, such as halting construction projects and limiting tourism, to pressure South Korea into reconsidering THAAD.

• Strategic Cooperation: Immediate cooperation on intercepting North Korean nuclear materials is recommended as a practical step to reduce the threat.

• Leadership and Communication: Green highlights the importance of having trusted advisors and officials engage in dialogue rather than relying on formal structures like the S&ED.

• Future Outlook: The summit between Trump and Xi is expected to be more of a symbolic gesture, with a focus on mutual respect and understanding rather than immediate policy changes.

Conclusion

The episode underscores the complex interplay between U.S. and China's strategic interests in the Asia-Pacific, particularly regarding North Korea. It suggests that while diplomatic efforts are important, they must be complemented by concrete security cooperation. The Chinese position on THAAD and their use of economic pressure are seen as ineffective and potentially counterproductive. The key to improving U.S.-China relations lies in fostering direct, trusted communication between senior officials and focusing on shared security goals rather than ideological or political posturing.