战略与国际研究中心-Policy-Papers-on-the-Americas_-Privatization-in-the-English_41页_166kb

报告摘要

Summary of "Privatization in the English-Speaking Caribbean: An Assessment"

Core Content

This document provides an analysis of privatization initiatives in the English-speaking Caribbean, focusing on Guyana, Trinidad and Tobago, Grenada, and Jamaica. It explores the historical context, objectives, forms of divestment, and the impact of privatization on the region's economies.

Main Objectives of Privatization in Developing Countries

Privatization in developing countries is driven by several key objectives, including:

Improving performance and efficiency of state-owned enterprises (SOEs)
Introducing competition in previously monopolized sectors
Increasing government income without raising taxes or increasing debt
Reducing the budgetary burden on the government
Settling foreign debt
Expanding the local equity market
Encouraging industrial development
Attracting foreign investment
Promoting economic growth
Increasing equity by narrowing income and resource access gaps

These objectives vary in importance depending on the country and its economic context.

Forms of Divestment

Divestment can occur through various mechanisms, including:

Contracting out services to the private sector
Establishing worker-owned enterprises via Employee Stock Ownership Programs or government employee-led purchases
Leasing SOEs to the private sector
Forming joint ventures with private sector interests or workers
Selling shares on the stock exchange
Conducting public offerings
Selling to former lessees
Entering into strategic partnerships with local or foreign entities

Privatization in the English-Speaking Caribbean

Historical Context

The privatization process in the English-speaking Caribbean is rooted in the post-independence era, where governments sought to assert economic sovereignty and control. This led to extensive public sector involvement in commercial and industrial activities, particularly in the mineral, sugar, and energy sectors.

Key Countries

Guyana

Privatization began in 1989 as part of a structural adjustment program.
Initial divestments included the Guyana Telecommunications Corporation (1990) and Guyana Bank for Industry and Commerce (1991).
The government faced criticism for the lack of transparency, speed, and the sale of profitable enterprises.
The privatization of the Guyana Electricity Corporation (GEC) was delayed due to political and economic challenges, with final agreements reached in early 1999.
As of 1999, the government had divested in several sectors, including distribution, transportation, and utilities.

Trinidad and Tobago

The government continued to acquire equity in various companies until the early 1990s.
Privatization started in 1987 under the National Alliance for Reconstruction (NAR) government.
Major SOEs such as TELCO, Trinidad Cement, and BWIA were partially or fully privatized.
The government also explored privatization of the water sector and planned to divest additional assets by the end of 1999.

Impact of Privatization

Positive Outcomes

No large-scale layoffs have occurred as expected.
Wages have increased in some privatized enterprises, such as Demerara Woods.
Efficiency and service quality have improved in sectors like telecommunications and electricity.

Challenges and Criticisms

Concerns over the lack of transparency and the absence of a clear framework.
Criticism for selling profitable enterprises and not achieving optimal prices.
Political resistance, particularly from labor unions and the opposition, regarding conditions such as increased electricity rates.
Some enterprises were sold to speculators, raising questions about the long-term benefits for the public.

Conclusion and Additional Considerations

Privatization in the English-speaking Caribbean has been a recent trend, primarily driven by the need for economic reform and structural adjustment. While the process has had some positive effects, it has also faced significant challenges, including political and economic uncertainties, lack of transparency, and public skepticism.

The study emphasizes the need for a more comprehensive and transparent approach to privatization, placing it within a broader context of economic development and efficiency rather than solely as a fiscal tool.

Key Information

Privatization in the Caribbean has been influenced by global economic trends and the pressure from multilateral institutions like the IMF and World Bank.
Jamaica is the only country in the region with a long history of public sector dominance, while others have only recently begun privatization efforts.
Challenges include the lack of expertise, political resistance, and concerns over transparency and fairness in the privatization process.
Positive effects include improved efficiency and service delivery in some sectors.
Tables provide detailed information on the privatization process in Guyana, Trinidad and Tobago, and Jamaica, including specific entities and financial figures.